At Bullseye Pizza, we’re proud to serve up our bold take on Buffalo-style pizza, wings, and subs right here in Getzville, NY. Under new local management, we’ve got a fresh focus on quality ingredients, fast service, and friendly vibes that make you feel right at home.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch, feeding a crowd, or just craving that perfect slice, we’re here to bring the flavor — with daily specials, signature sauces, and a side of nostalgia.
Come in, kick back, and taste what makes Bullseye the neighborhood favorite.
Large Pizza 1 Topping – Cheese and one regular topping piled high on our fresh‑baked crust, baked golden & served piping hot. Order online for quick carryout...
2 Large Pizzas
41.0
2 Large Pizzas 1 topping
Small Pizza & 10 Wings
26.0
Small Pizza & 10 Wings
Large Pizza & 20 Wings
46.0
Large Pizza & 20 Wings – Cheese and one regular topping piled high on our hand‑tossed crust, baked golden & served piping hot. Order online for quick carryou...
Sheet Pizza & 30 Wings
66.0
Sheet Pizza & 30 Wings – Cheese and one regular topping and 30 wings in any of our signature sauces
Traditional Pizza
Price (USD)
Cheese Slice
3.2
Cheese Slice – Cheese piled high on our artisan crust, baked golden & served piping hot. Order online for quick carryout or delivery!
1 Topping Slice
3.7
Slice 1 Topping – Cheese and one topping piled high on our stone‑baked crust, baked golden & served piping hot. Order online for quick carryout or delivery!
Specialty Slice
4.1
Specialty Slice – (Varies – see specialty pizzas) piled high on our stone‑baked crust, baked golden & served piping hot. Order online for quick carryout or d...
Personal Pizza 1 Topping
11.0
Personal 9" Pizza with 1 Topping
Small Cheese Pizza
14.0
Small Cheese Pizza (6 Slices) - Add $1.99 per additional topping
Wings / Chicken Fingers
JUMBO WINGS & FINGERS SERVED WITH BLEU CHEESE & CARROTS. YOUR CHOICE OF SAUCE (HOT • MEDIUM • MILD • BBQ • HOT BBQ • HONEY MUSTARD • CAJUN
•GARLIC PARM • STINGING HONEY GARLIC (THE ZING SAUCE) AND OUR FAMOUS EVERYTHING WING SAUCE
All subs below come on a toasted white or wheat Costanzo roll, with lettuce, tomato and choice of cheese (hoagie cheese, mozzarella, swiss, american, provolone and pepper jack).
Price (USD)
Assorted Sub
10.0
Capicola, Ham and Salami
Bacon Sub (BLT)
9.0
Bacon Sub – Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato
Capicola
9.0
Cheese Sub
8.0
Cheese Sub – choice of 2 types of cheese, stacked and melted in the oven.
Club (Turkey & Bacon)
10.0
Hot Sub/Wraps
Our hot subs are built to satisfy, with toasted rolls, melted cheese, and generous layers of meats and toppings. From steak and chicken to crispy tenders, every bite hits the spot.
Price (USD)
Bacon Cheeseburger Sub
12.0
Burgers topped with American Cheese and Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato
Cheeseburger Sub
11.0
Burgers topped with American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato
Cheesesteak
12.0
see "The Works"
Chicken Cheesesteak
11.0
Chicken Cheesesteak – see "The Works - Chicken"
Chicken Finger Sub
11.0
Chicken Finger Sub – juicy chicken tenders tossed in your choice of signature sauces, fried crispy outside & tender inside.
Specialty Sandwiches
Our specialty sandwiches bring the heat and the flavor. Choose from classic hot dogs, a zesty Greek chicken wrap, or a savory grilled chicken wrap—each made fresh and loaded with bold ingredients.
Price (USD)
Grilled Chicken Wrap
10.0
Grilled Chicken Sandwich – stacked with Grilled chicken (with standard toppings such as lettuce/tomato)
Chicken Greek Wrap
10.0
Chicken Greek Wrap – stacked with Lettuce, tomato, black olives, green peppers, onion, feta cheese, Greek dressing.
Sahlens Hot Dog
4.0
Sahlens Hot Dog – delicious choice crafted with quality ingredients and packed with flavor. Order now!
Beverages
Stay refreshed with our full lineup of beverages. From ice-cold sodas and bottled water to juices and more, we've got the perfect drink to wash it all down.
Price (USD)
No items found.
Additional Sides
Crispy, cheesy, and made to share—or not. Our sides include golden fries, warm pretzel sticks, gooey mozzarella sticks, onion rings, and more perfect pairings for your main meal.
Price (USD)
French Fries
4.0
Crinkle Cut Style French Fry
Cajun French Fries
4.3
Crinkle Cut Style French Fry tossed in our House Made Cajun Seasoning
Onion Rings
7.0
Onion Rings – flavorful side to complement any pizza, wings, or sub.
Pretzel Sticks
5.5
Pretzel Sticks – flavorful side to complement any pizza, wings, or sub.
Garlic Bread
6.0
Bread covered in Garlic Herb Butter and Parmesan Cheese and baked
Tacos
Tacos packed with bold flavor and fresh ingredients. Choose from beef, steak, chicken, or cheesy goodness—all served in warm shells for a satisfying bite every time.
Price (USD)
Beef & Cheese Taco
8.5
Beef & Cheese Taco –loaded with beef, cheese, lettuce, tomato, sour cream and taco sauce, all dressed up in warm tortilla shells, delivering bold flavors in every bite.
Chicken & Cheese Taco
9.5
Chicken & Cheese Taco – loaded with chicken, cheese, lettuce, tomato, sour cream and taco sauce, all dressed up in warm tortilla shells, delivering bold flavors in every bite.
Steak & Cheese Taco
10.0
Steak & Cheese Taco – loaded with Steak, cheese, lettuce, tomato, sour cream and taco sauce, all dressed up in warm tortilla shells, delivering bold flavors in every bite.
Sweet Treats
Finish strong with something sweet! From Carson's cookies to funnel fries, our desserts are the perfect way to treat yourself after a slice (or three).
Price (USD)
Rocky Road Brownie
2.5
Rocky Road Brownie – sweet finish to your meal that satisfies every dessert craving.
Carson's Cookies
4.0
Chocolate Chunk Cookie – sweet finish to your meal that satisfies every dessert craving.
Funnel Fries (Powdered Sugar or Cinnamon Sugar)
7.0
Funnel Fries (Powdered Sugar or Cinnamon Sugar) – sweet finish to your meal that satisfies every dessert craving.
Kids Menu
Tasty, kid-sized favorites made just for the little ones! From cheesy slices to crispy tenders, our Kids Menu keeps things simple, delicious, and fun — no complaints at the table guaranteed.
Price (USD)
Chicken Fingers & Fries (2 Chicken Fingers)
7.0
Chicken Fingers & Fries (2 Chicken Fingers) – juicy chicken tossed in your choice of signature sauces, fried crispy outside & tender inside. This kids meal comes with a side of fries
Slice And Fries
6.0
Slice And Fries – kid‑approved portion with classic flavors to keep little tummies happy.
Side Sauces
Take your meal to the next level with our signature side sauces — perfect for dunking, drizzling, or devouring. From zesty to creamy, we've got the flavor boost you’re craving. (Hot, Med, Mild, BBQ, Honey Mustard, Stinging Honey Garlic, Ranch and of course Blue Cheese)
Price (USD)
Side Bleu Cheese
0.9
Side Bleu Cheese – flavorful side to complement any pizza, wings, or sub.
Side Ranch
0.9
Side Ranch – flavorful side to complement any pizza, wings, or sub.
Side Dressing
0.9
Side Dressing – flavorful side to complement any pizza, wings, or sub.
Side Wing Sauce
0.9
Side Wing Sauce – juicy chicken tossed in your choice of signature sauces, fried crispy outside & tender inside. Perfect game‑day bite—order a batch now!